Charity accounts don't speak the same language yet. A new standard and better data could help.

Two people comparing charity financial reports: one holds two differently formatted reports, the other checks a single standardized report with green checkmarks on a laptop
On this page5 sections
  1. Why the numbers don't line up
  2. Researchers have been saying this for years
  3. Two pieces of an answer
  4. Where this could lead
  5. What you can do in the meantime

This is a guest post by a Chartered Management Accountant at an international nonprofit, who has chosen not to be named. Figures were checked on 31 October 2026.

Say you want to support malaria prevention, and someone recommends the Against Malaria Foundation. You look it up on GiveRadar and find that it isn't one charity. There are separate registered charities in several countries, and six of them have financial figures on GiveRadar:

Where it's registered Latest income reported
United States $119.4m
United Kingdom £113.9m
Canada C$6.4m
Australia A$3.8m
New Zealand NZ$0.3m
Ireland €0.2m

These are for financial years ending in 2024 or 2025, so they don't even cover the same period. The different currencies are the obvious problem, and the easy one to fix. The harder problem is that each of these charities keeps its accounts under different national rules. "Income" in one row doesn't quite mean what it means in the next. Neither does "spent on the cause", or even "the year".

That matters to more people than accountants. Donors, foundations, journalists and regulators increasingly look at charities in other countries. Most of them assume the numbers line up. They often don't.

Why the numbers don't line up

A few examples show how much the rules can move a figure.

Take a charity that is promised a three-year grant. Under UK charity rules, it books grant income once it is entitled to it, which can mean recording all three years' money in the year the grant is signed. Under US rules, a grant with conditions attached is booked only as the conditions are met. Both systems have tests for what counts as a condition, and they are worded differently, so the same grant can show up as one bumper year in one set of accounts and three ordinary years in another.

Then there's the figure donors love most: how much of the money goes to the cause. UK charities spread their back-office costs, such as finance and IT, across their charitable work. US charities report those costs in a separate "management and general" line. Dutch charities show management and administration separately too, but group other costs their own way. In a sample of a few hundred charities I pulled from GiveRadar, the median UK charity reported about 91% of spending going to its programs, the median US charity about 85% and the median Dutch charity about 82%. The sample is small (fewer than 60 of the UK charities had the figure at all), so treat these numbers as an illustration, not national averages. Some of the gap may be real, but differences in how costs are classified probably explain part of it.

Some countries make charities show which money was given for a specific purpose and can't be used for anything else. Others don't. Without that split, you can't tell whether a charity with healthy-looking reserves could actually use them in a crisis. And in many countries, smaller charities simply count cash in and cash out, which can give a very different picture from full accounts for the same year.

None of this is anyone's fault. Each country built rules that made sense locally. The trouble starts when you put the results side by side.

Researchers have been saying this for years

Academics noticed the problem long before most charity databases existed. In 2017, a team led by Janet Mack compared the published accounts of four charities working in the same field, with similar income, from Australia, England, Ireland and New Zealand. They found shared problems in the concepts behind nonprofit reporting and argued for harmonized international standards. A 2021 study of European rules found substantial differences between countries in how they treat donations, fixed assets such as buildings, and volunteer time, and linked them to different national traditions. Earlier work compared the UK and New Zealand, which share a lot of legal history: New Zealand applied the same reporting rules to charities as to other organizations, while the UK developed separate rules for charities.

People working in the sector seem broadly supportive. A 2018 survey of people involved in nonprofit financial reporting drew 605 responses from 179 countries. Respondents, especially those in developing countries, were generally open to international standards for nonprofits, provided the standards improved accounting and accountability. Whether they should apply to small organizations, or be mandatory, was left open.

The problem was well described. What was missing were the tools to do something about it.

Two pieces of an answer

The first piece is a common rulebook. In October 2025, after six years of consultation run by the accountancy body CIPFA and the nonprofit network Humentum, the International Non-Profit Accounting Standard was published. It goes by INPAS. ICAEW describes it as the first global accounting standard designed specifically for nonprofits, rather than for companies or governments with nonprofits squeezed in.

INPAS tackles several of the problems above. It has one set of rules for when grant and donation income is recognized, based on whether the charity has to deliver something in return. It requires charities to show restricted and unrestricted funds separately. It has specific rules on fundraising costs and on how shared support costs are charged to restricted funds. A companion guide sets out a single format for reporting on individual grants, tied back to the audited accounts, so a charity with ten funders could, if the funders agreed, send one kind of report instead of ten.

Adoption has started where the need is greatest. Kenya's accountancy body, ICPAK, committed to adopting INPAS soon after its launch and has since published a national roadmap, with full reporting under the standard expected from 2029. In Uganda, the accountancy body is co-hosting a 2026 NGO symposium to help organizations prepare. Countries with well-established rules, like the UK and the US, will probably take longer, if they adopt it at all.

The second piece is somewhere to see it all. A common rulebook only helps if someone can actually put charities from different countries next to each other. That is rarer than you might think. The best-known charity data platforms, such as Candid, Charity Navigator and ProPublica's Nonprofit Explorer, are built mainly around US tax filings. GiveRadar lists more than 7.9 million organizations in more than 100 countries from official registers, and holds financial filings for over 960,000 charities in 17 countries, including the UK, Canada, Australia, New Zealand, Ireland, the Netherlands, Norway, Belgium, Latvia and Mexico. Its profiles name the registers the data comes from.

That breadth is why the Against Malaria Foundation example above was easy to find. It also makes GiveRadar a useful place for an international standard to become visible. Like any database built from many registers, it has gaps and lags: some figures are a year or more behind the register, and a field doesn't always mean the same thing from one country to the next. Those are the same comparability problems this post is about, and they are worth keeping in mind when reading any cross-border figure, including the ones above.

Where this could lead

Picture a foundation in Oslo looking for a partner organization in Nairobi. Today, it would probably ask for the partner's accounts, find them in an unfamiliar format, and send its own reporting template on top. If both countries' charities increasingly report under INPAS, the foundation could look up the partner, see its accounts in a structure it already knows, check how much of its money is unrestricted, and accept grant reports that tie straight back to the audited figures. A database covering both countries could show the two charities side by side and say clearly that the comparison is fair, because both follow the same rules.

We aren't there yet, and it would be misleading to pretend otherwise. INPAS is voluntary unless a country or funder requires it. Many small charities will sensibly keep simpler cash accounts. The UK and US will keep their own standards for the foreseeable future. Not everyone agrees that a nonprofit-specific standard is the right answer, either: Cordery and Baskerville argued that separate rules for charities add to the burden on the people who prepare, audit and read their accounts. For years, any honest database will show a mix of systems and will need to say which is which.

Still, both pieces are now being built at the same time. INPAS gives charities a shared way to keep their accounts, and a database like GiveRadar is where the rest of us can actually compare them.

What you can do in the meantime

If you give to charities abroad, compare charities within the same country where you can, and look at several years of figures rather than one.

If you run a nonprofit, publish your accounts, use your official registration number everywhere, and check that your profile on databases like GiveRadar is accurate. If your country is moving to INPAS, say clearly in your accounts when you start following it.

If you fund organizations in other countries, ask them to show restricted and unrestricted money separately, and consider accepting INPAS accounts and grant reports instead of your own formats.

If you research or write about charities, say which national rules your figures come from before drawing conclusions across borders.

Charity numbers will never be perfectly comparable. They can get a lot closer than they are now.

Share this article
Matt Timmermans, Founder of GiveRadar
Written by
Founder of GiveRadar

Matt built GiveRadar after trying to research small charities abroad and finding almost nothing. Everything here comes from the same official registry data the platform runs on.

Comments

Leave a comment

Start here

Check any charity before you give

Search 7.9M+ nonprofits across 100+ countries, free, and no account needed.